C Programming: Preprocessor, macros as tokens

3.6k Views Asked by At

I'm trying to do something that is conceptually similar to this, but can't seem to get it to work (error shown at end) any ideas?

#include <stdio.h>

int main( int argc , char const *argv[] )
{
  int abc_def_ghi = 42;
  #define SUFFIX ghi
  #define VAR(prefix) prefix##_def_##SUFFIX
  printf( "%d\n" , VAR(abc) );
  return 0;
}

// untitled:8: error: ‘abc_def_SUFFIX’ undeclared (first use in this function)
3

There are 3 best solutions below

3
On BEST ANSWER

You just need additional indirection:

#include <stdio.h>

int main( int argc , char const *argv[] )
{
  int abc_def_ghi = 42;
  #define SUFFIX ghi
  #define VAR3(prefix, suffix) prefix##_def_##suffix
  #define VAR2(prefix, suffix) VAR3(prefix, suffix)
  #define VAR(prefix) VAR2(prefix, SUFFIX)
  printf( "%d\n" , VAR(abc) );
  return 0;
}

Even though it looks redundant, it's not.

1
On

The usual idiom for correctly using the stringizing (#) or token pasting (##) pre-processing operators is to use a 2nd level of indirection. (What are the applications of the ## preprocessor operator and gotchas to consider?).

#define STRINGIFY2( x) #x
#define STRINGIFY(x) STRINGIFY2(x)

#define PASTE2( a, b) a##b
#define PASTE( a, b) PASTE2( a, b)

Then:

int main( int argc , char const *argv[] )
{
  int abc_def_ghi = 42;
  #define SUFFIX ghi
  #define VAR(prefix) PASTE( prefix, PASTE( _def_, SUFFIX))
  printf( "%d\n" , VAR(abc) );
  return 0;
}

Should give you the results you're looking for.

Basically, what happens is that processing of the # and ## operators takes place before macro replacement. Then another round of macro replacement occurs. So if you want macros to be used along with those operations you have to use a 1st level that simply does the replacement - otherwise the stringizing or pasting happens first, and the macros aren't macros anymore- they're whatever the 1st round of stringizing/pasting produces.

To put it more directly - the first level of macro allows the macro parameters to be replaced, then the 2nd level of macro replacement does the stringify/token-pasting operation.

1
On

This works with sufficient levels of indirection. While another answer is plenty adequate, I want offer this chunk of code as a demo:

#define SUFFIX ghi

#define VAR1(prefix) prefix##_def_##SUFFIX
VAR1(abc)

#define VAR2_(prefix, sfx) prefix##_def_##sfx
#define VAR2(prefix) VAR2_(prefix,SUFFIX)
VAR2(abc)

#define VAR3_(prefix, sfx) prefix##_def_##sfx
#define VAR3x(prefix,sfx) VAR3_(prefix,sfx)
#define VAR3(prefix) VAR3x(prefix,SUFFIX)
VAR3(abc)

Save this is a text file, x.c, and only preprocess it.

gcc -E x.c

Observe and ponder. I don't quite understand it entirely myself. Just spend two hours trying to get a macro using stringify to work. It is interesting to see that double indirection is sometimes needed.