(require '[clojure.test.check.generators :as gen])
(def ACTIONS
{:create-new-user #{}
:edit-user #{:create-new-user}
:create-new-board #{:create-new-user}
:edit-board #{:create-new-board}
:create-new-anonymous-comment #{:create-new-board}
:create-new-signed-comment #{:create-new-board}
:edit-comment-text #{:create-new-anonymous-comment :create-new-signed-comment}
:edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity #{:create-new-anonymous-comment :create-new-signed-comment}
:flip-anonymity #{:create-new-anonymous-comment :create-new-signed-comment}
:vote-comment-up #{:create-new-anonymous-comment :create-new-signed-comment}
:vote-comment-down #{:create-new-anonymous-comment :create-new-signed-comment}})
(def actions (-> ACTIONS keys vec gen/elements gen/vector))
(defn filter-actions-into-logical-order [as]
(let [seen (atom #{})]
(filter
(fn [v]
(let [required (get ACTIONS v)
valid? (or (some? (some required @seen))
(and (empty? @seen) (= v :create-new-user)))]
(when valid?
(swap! seen conj v)
true)))
as)))
(def ordered-actions (gen/fmap #(-> % filter-actions-into-logical-order vec) actions))
As an example of the two generators:
# (last (gen/sample actions 100))
[:edit-user :vote-comment-down :flip-anonymity :vote-comment-down :vote-comment-down :vote-comment-up :edit-user :create-new-anonymous-comment :edit-board :create-new-signed-comment :vote-comment-up :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :edit-user :create-new-signed-comment :edit-user :edit-user :vote-comment-down :edit-user :vote-comment-down :create-new-user :vote-comment-down :create-new-user :create-new-user :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :create-new-user :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :create-new-anonymous-comment :edit-comment-text :create-new-board :vote-comment-down :flip-anonymity :create-new-signed-comment :vote-comment-up :create-new-user :create-new-signed-comment :edit-user :create-new-user :create-new-board :vote-comment-down :create-new-board :create-new-board :create-new-board :edit-board :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :edit-user :edit-comment-text :create-new-signed-comment :vote-comment-up :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :flip-anonymity :create-new-anonymous-comment :create-new-anonymous-comment :edit-board :create-new-signed-comment :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :edit-board :vote-comment-up :edit-comment-text :create-new-board :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :create-new-board :vote-comment-down :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :vote-comment-up :create-new-user :vote-comment-up :edit-comment-text :edit-board :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :flip-anonymity :edit-board :create-new-anonymous-comment :flip-anonymity :create-new-signed-comment :edit-user :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :edit-comment-text :edit-comment-text :create-new-user :flip-anonymity :edit-user :vote-comment-up :edit-user :create-new-user :edit-comment-text :edit-comment-text :flip-anonymity :edit-comment-text :edit-board :flip-anonymity :edit-board :edit-comment-text :edit-user :create-new-user :flip-anonymity]
# (last (gen/sample ordered-actions 100))
[:create-new-user :edit-user :edit-user :create-new-board :edit-board :edit-user :create-new-anonymous-comment :edit-comment-text :edit-board :edit-user :edit-user :vote-comment-up :edit-comment-text :create-new-signed-comment :edit-comment-text :create-new-board :edit-comment-text :edit-comment-text :edit-comment-text :vote-comment-up :vote-comment-up :edit-board :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :create-new-signed-comment :create-new-anonymous-comment :create-new-signed-comment :edit-user :create-new-anonymous-comment :edit-board :create-new-board :create-new-anonymous-comment :create-new-board :flip-anonymity :create-new-anonymous-comment :edit-board :vote-comment-up :vote-comment-down :edit-board :edit-comment-text :edit-user :edit-comment-text :flip-anonymity :create-new-signed-comment :vote-comment-up :edit-comment-text-and-flip-anonymity :vote-comment-up :create-new-signed-comment :edit-comment-text :create-new-signed-comment :create-new-anonymous-comment :edit-board :create-new-anonymous-comment]
ACTIONS
is a map where the key is the name of the action, and the value is the (OR based) dependency for that action. As an example, you must first :create-new-user
before you can do anything, you must :create-new-board
before you can :edit-board
, and you must have at least one :create-new-*-comment
before you can :edit-comment-text
.
The code above seems to work, but it is ugly. 1) I don't like how filter-actions-into-logical-order
code has to have a specific exception for :create-new-user
. 2) I don't like that I am basically taking the list of random actions, and filtering it down until the actions make ordered sense.
I am wondering how others would generate a sequence of actions like this using test.check? Surely there must be a way to do so using only generators?
Well,
filter-into-logical-order
could arguably be cleaner with a switch toreduce
but that still puts out about 30% empty vectors for me and it's not a generator. I'm not sure the documented combinators actually support what you want, though.
gen/vector
does not appear to support handing a vector-in-construction to its inner generator so it can know what values are allowed, which is kinda the structure your requirements need.