Matlab fourier descriptors what's wrong?

Question

I am using Gonzalez frdescp function to get Fourier descriptors of a boundary. I use this code, and I get two totally different sets of numbers describing two identical but different in scale shapes.

So what is wrong?

im = imread('c:\classes\a1.png');
im = im2bw(im);
b = bwboundaries(im);
f = frdescp(b{1}); // fourier descriptors for the boundary of the first object ( my   pic only contains one object anyway )
// Normalization
f = f(2:20); // getting the first 20 & deleting the dc component
f = abs(f) ;
f = f/f(1);

Why do I get different descriptors for identical - but different in scale - two circles?

Answer 1

The problem is that the frdescp code (I used this code, that should be the same as referred by you) is written also in order to center the Fourier descriptors.

If you want to describe your shape in a correct way, it is mandatory to mantain some descriptors that are symmetric with respect to the one representing the DC component.

The following image summarize the concept:

In order to solve your problem (and others like yours), I wrote the following two functions:

function descriptors = fourierdescriptor( boundary )
    %I assume that the boundary is a N x 2 matrix
    %Also, N must be an even number

    np = size(boundary, 1);

    s = boundary(:, 1) + i*boundary(:, 2);

    descriptors = fft(s);

    descriptors = [descriptors((1+(np/2)):end); descriptors(1:np/2)];
end

function significativedescriptors = getsignificativedescriptors( alldescriptors, num )
    %num is the number of significative descriptors (in your example, is was 20)
    %In the following, I assume that num and size(alldescriptors,1) are even numbers

    dim = size(alldescriptors, 1);

    if num >= dim
        significativedescriptors = alldescriptors;
    else
        a = (dim/2 - num/2) + 1;
        b = dim/2 + num/2;

        significativedescriptors = alldescriptors(a : b);
    end
end

Know, you can use the above functions as follows:

im = imread('test.jpg');
im = im2bw(im);
b = bwboundaries(im);
b = b{1};

%force the number of boundary points to be even
if mod(size(b,1), 2) ~= 0
    b = [b; b(end, :)];
end

%define the number of significative descriptors I want to extract (it must be even)
numdescr = 20;

%Now, you can extract all fourier descriptors...
f = fourierdescriptor(b);
%...and get only the most significative:
f_sign = getsignificativedescriptors(f, numdescr);

Answer 2

I just went through the same problem with you.

According to this link, if you want invariant to scaling, make the comparison ratio-like, for example by dividing every Fourier coefficient by the DC-coefficient. f*1 = f1/f[0], f*[2]/f[0], and so on. Thus, you need to use the DC-coefficient where the f(1) in your code is not the actual DC-coefficient after your step "f = f(2:20); % getting the first 20 & deleting the dc component". I think the problem can be solved by keeping the value of the DC-coefficient first, the code after adjusted should be like follows:

% Normalization
DC = f(1);
f = f(2:20); % getting the first 20 & deleting the dc component
f = abs(f) ; % use magnitudes to be invariant to translation & rotation
f = f/DC; % divide the Fourier coefficients by the DC-coefficient to be invariant to scale