I am currently trying to do model checking with PyMC where my model is a Bernoulli model and I have a Beta prior. I want to do both a (i) gof plot as well as (ii) calculate the posterior predictive p-value.
I have got my code running with a Binomial model, but I am quite struggling to find the right way of making a Bernoulli model working. Unfortunately, there is no example anywhere that I can work with. My code looks like the following:
import pymc as mc
import numpy as np
alpha = 2
beta = 2
n = 13
yes = np.array([1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0,0,0])
p = mc.Beta('p',alpha,beta)
surv = mc.Bernoulli('surv',p=p,observed=True,value=yes)
surv_sim = mc.Bernoulli('surv_sim',p=p)
mc_est = mc.MCMC({'p':p,'surv':surv,'surv_sim':surv_sim})
mc_est.sample(10000,5000,2)
import matplotlib.pylab as plt
plt.hist(mc_est.surv_sim.trace(),bins=range(0,3),normed=True)
plt.figure()
plt.hist(mc_est.p.trace(),bins=100,normed=True)
mc.Matplot.gof_plot(mc_est.surv_sim.trace(), 10/13., name='surv')
#here I have issues
D = mc.discrepancy(yes, surv_sim, p.trace())
mc.Matplot.discrepancy_plot(D)
The main problem I am having is in determining the expected values for the discrepancy
function. Just using p.trace()
does not work here, as these are the probabilities. Somehow, I need to incorporate the sample size here, but I am struggling to do that in a similar way as I would do it for a Binomial model. I am also not quite sure, if I am doing the gof_plot
correctly.
Hope someone can help me out here! Thanks!
Per the
discrepancy
function doc string, the parameters are:So you need to correct two things:
1) modify your simulated results to have size
n
(e.g., 13 in your example):surv_sim = mc.Bernoulli('surv_sim', p=p, size=n)
2) encapsulate your
p.trace()
with thebernoulli_expval
method:D = mc.discrepancy(yes, surv_sim.trace(), mc.bernoulli_expval(p.trace()))
(
bernoulli_expval
just spits backp
.)With those two changes, I get the following: